Ask a Football Official anything

514 Questions

Last Answer on January 23, 2021

I know the rule book completely. So, your answer should be that you cannot answer the question, you can only repeat the rule.

Asked by Steve in motown about 6 years ago

Thank you

Concerning dead ball fouls, why are they only enforced if it happens after the play, why not if they happen during the play? By definition, fouls should not happen, period. Why offset during the play but not after? Makes no sense to me.

Asked by dmuellenberg over 6 years ago

Yes, fouls happen...after the play they "shouldn't" happen because the play is over. The player screwed up by going after an opponent after the play.

509 Votes

QB in pocket watching receivers. Long hair protrudes from helmet.
A. Unblocked DL grabs by hair and pulls to ground.
B. DL being blocked reaches out for anything and grabs hair, pulls to ground.
Is either illegal?

Asked by JAMES FRANCIS over 6 years ago

Long hair is on the player. He is not being pulled down by the facemask or a helmet opening nor is he being pulled down by grabbing inside the collar (horse collar tackle). There is no foul.

508 Votes

On a safety, QB flagged for illegal touch (bad snap & kick ball out instead of trying to recover). Smart play, but ref made the other coach choose to decline the penalty to get safety, No option for safety & apply penalty on freekick, Correct call?

Asked by Paul E Miller over 6 years ago

There was no "illegal touch"; the foul was for illegally kicking the ball. The result of the play - the ball going over the endline because of the kicking - was a safety. You can't have the result of the play and the penalty.

508 Votes

Also on Jobstr...

SWAT Team Commander (Retired)

How do you decide whether to try and kill a hostage taker?

Audiologist

Are earbuds dangerous for my ears?

CrossFit Coach

Are Crossfit gyms profitable right out of the gate?

In the Browns vs. Bengals game yesterday, CLE TE appears to come down with catch, but ball is stripped out by CIN player as both go to ground. Eventually ruled an INT. Why wasn't CIN player ruled "down by contact?"

Asked by JLINK8 over 6 years ago

Yiu write there isxa strip as they go to the ground. Meaning no one is down. So if possession changes before they go to the ground and the defender has control once on the ground, you have an INT.

503 Votes

if an offensive player is driving towards the end zone and fumbles the ball in the field of play before reaching the end zone and the ball rolls into and then out of the end zone, why is it that the defense is rewarded possession of the football?

Asked by Steve in Motown about 6 years ago

By definition, what you have there is a touchback. And it isn't so much that the defense is rewarded as it is awarded the ball. It was the offense that put the ball into and through the end zone and that's a touchback.

503 Votes

Do you ever get booed?

Asked by They have a chance over 6 years ago

Uhhh, yes.

498 Votes

Showing 386 - 392

Show All

9 More Answers by Football Official

Last 7

53 54 55 56 57 58

...

Next 7 Answers

Football Official

Ask me anything!

What do YOU do?

I know the rule book completely. So, your answer should be that you cannot answer the question, you can only repeat the rule.

Concerning dead ball fouls, why are they only enforced if it happens after the play, why not if they happen during the play? By definition, fouls should not happen, period. Why offset during the play but not after? Makes no sense to me.

QB in pocket watching receivers. Long hair protrudes from helmet.
A. Unblocked DL grabs by hair and pulls to ground.
B. DL being blocked reaches out for anything and grabs hair, pulls to ground.
Is either illegal?

On a safety, QB flagged for illegal touch (bad snap & kick ball out instead of trying to recover). Smart play, but ref made the other coach choose to decline the penalty to get safety, No option for safety & apply penalty on freekick, Correct call?

Also on Jobstr...

In the Browns vs. Bengals game yesterday, CLE TE appears to come down with catch, but ball is stripped out by CIN player as both go to ground. Eventually ruled an INT. Why wasn't CIN player ruled "down by contact?"

if an offensive player is driving towards the end zone and fumbles the ball in the field of play before reaching the end zone and the ball rolls into and then out of the end zone, why is it that the defense is rewarded possession of the football?

Do you ever get booed?

Football Official

Ask me anything!

What do YOU do?

I know the rule book completely. So, your answer should be that you cannot answer the question, you can only repeat the rule.

Concerning dead ball fouls, why are they only enforced if it happens after the play, why not if they happen during the play? By definition, fouls should not happen, period. Why offset during the play but not after? Makes no sense to me.

QB in pocket watching receivers. Long hair protrudes from helmet.A. Unblocked DL grabs by hair and pulls to ground.B. DL being blocked reaches out for anything and grabs hair, pulls to ground.Is either illegal?

On a safety, QB flagged for illegal touch (bad snap & kick ball out instead of trying to recover). Smart play, but ref made the other coach choose to decline the penalty to get safety, No option for safety & apply penalty on freekick, Correct call?

Also on Jobstr...

In the Browns vs. Bengals game yesterday, CLE TE appears to come down with catch, but ball is stripped out by CIN player as both go to ground. Eventually ruled an INT. Why wasn't CIN player ruled "down by contact?"

if an offensive player is driving towards the end zone and fumbles the ball in the field of play before reaching the end zone and the ball rolls into and then out of the end zone, why is it that the defense is rewarded possession of the football?

Do you ever get booed?

Login

Forgot Your Password?

Register

QB in pocket watching receivers. Long hair protrudes from helmet.
A. Unblocked DL grabs by hair and pulls to ground.
B. DL being blocked reaches out for anything and grabs hair, pulls to ground.
Is either illegal?